WOW! What a controversial doctrinal topic!
This ranks right up there with Tongues, Divorce, and drums & guitars in church for those
who thrive on divisive opinions. This is one of those topics that
require absolute trust in the complete Inspiration & Authority of Scripture,
together with a sound Biblical Interpretive Methodology (Hermeneutics). Of
course, prayer for understanding is essential, but you've probably heard many
teachers say something like, "I prayed about this ... and God told
me...". The honest
Bible student must see what scripture says, and if the scripture doesn't say
much on a subject, then any understanding must be conviction or opinion,
and not unpleasant dogmatism.
And, I caution the reader to discern whether this is a
"Cardinal Doctrine" - essential to salvation and godly living, or a
"Secondary Doctrine", or is it a "Conviction", or "Opinion"; and so the student must discern
with what vehemence to 'argue' their case.
For me, this ranks as a personal "conviction",
and not either a "Secondary" nor "Cardinal"
doctrine.
I know many fine teachers who are women; and such widely
respected Bible Scholar greats as J. Vernon McGee have studied the scriptures
extensively, and do not restrict women from any teaching situation in then
church. I certainly do not rank among such scholars ...
but nevertheless, with those disclaimers, I'll plunge in and
give my own understanding. So now, follow me through my limited understanding of the
few scriptures on this subject, and be extremely careful about
trying to bring in (or explain away) extra-biblical or cultural explanations.
Women Are Not to Teach Men in NT
churches - 1 Tim 2:11-14
This is a matter of the biblically defined 'role' of women
in the church, and does not denote 'value' as a child of God, intelligence, or lower
dignity.]
Applicable scripture and ministry examples:
1 Tim 2:11-14
and appropriate word studies
"A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a
woman to teach or to have authority over a man: she must be silent.
For Adam was formed first, then Eve." (NIV) Hence, Teaching & Authority are based
upon the creative order - not ability, experience, gifts, culture, or common church
practice. The creative order hasnt changed.
Teach - 1321 didasko did-as'-ko}
a prolonged (causative) form of a primary verb dao (to learn);
to teach; to hold discourse with others in order to instruct them; deliver didactic
discourses; to be a teacher; to discharge the office of a teacher; conduct one's self
as a teacher; to teach one; to impart instruction; instill doctrine into one; the thing
taught or enjoined; to explain or expound a thing; to teach one something.
This word is related to 1319 didaskalia did-as-kal-ee'-ah} AV - doctrine, precepts
Note that the word Teach used is in the context of an office, position,
or formal setting, not just answering some short questions to someone.
Authority - 831 authenteo ow-then-teh'-o}
from a compound of 846 and an obsolete hentes (a worker); v
AV - usurp authority over 1; 1
1) one who with his own hands kills another or himself
2) one who acts on his own authority, autocratic
3) an absolute master
4) to govern, exercise dominion over one
Some have imagined an escape clause here since a woman could be
under church authority rather than her own and teach men. However, she still couldnt
"teach" and would have to be silent, as is further restricted by
Paul in both 1 Tim 2:12 and 1 Cor 14:34.
Note also that women in the OT did not have authority over men (except wicked
queens).
Also, a good follow-on study is of the Prophetess Deborah, who did not exercise
authority (Barak did), but rather declared Gods plans (expounded). See Judges chap
4,5.
Silent - 2271 hesuchia hay-soo-khee'-ah}
from 2272;; n f
AV - silent 3, quietness 1; 4
1) quietness
1a) description of the life of one who stays at home doing his own
work, and does not officiously meddle with the affairs of others
2) silence
Notice that this isnt the same word thats used in 1 Cor 14:34, but is a
synonym with a different emphasis.
Galatians 3:28 (Col 3:11) "There is neither Jew nor Greek , there is neither
bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus."
See the context preceding. All Christians have equal standing in our salvation.
Function in the body of Christ is different.
Titus 2:3-5 Women are to teach other women.
1 Cor 14:34-38 and appropriate word studies
"women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to
speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says. 35 If they want to inquire about
something, they should ask their own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful
for a woman to speak in the church. 36 Did the word of God originate with you? Or are you
the only people it has reached? 37 If anybody thinks he is a prophet or spiritually
gifted, let him acknowledge that what I am writing to you is the Lord's command. 38 If he
ignores this, he himself will be ignored."
Note in v 34 that the Old Testament "Law" in reference to this issue is
referred to as still operative, since the NT did not supersede the creative order. Note
also, that Paul is referring to formal church settings here.
Silent - 4601 sigao see-gah'-o} from 4602;; v
AV - hold (one's) peace 4, keep silence 3, keep close 1, keep secret 1; 9
1) to keep silence, hold one's peace
2) to be kept in silence, be concealed
Disgraceful - 149 aischron ahee-skhron'} from 150;; n n
AV - shame 3; 3
1. shame, base, dishonorable
Other Word Studies
Deaconess (RSV) - Servant (NIV), Same word as Deacon 1249
diakonos dee-ak'-on-os}
probably from an obsolete diako (to run on errands, cf 1377); TDNT - 2:88,152; n m/f
AV - minister 20, servant 8, deacon 3; 31
1) one who executes the commands of another, esp. of a master, a servant, attendant,
minister
References to NT women are to Deaconesses (servants in the church), and not to teaching.
Deacon - 1249 diakonos dee-ak'-on-os} probably from an obsolete diako (to run on
errands, cf 1377); TDNT - 2:88,152; n m/f
AV - minister 20, servant 8, deacon 3; 31
1) one who executes the commands of another, esp. of a master, a servant, attendant,
minister
1a) the servant of a king
1b) a deacon, one who, by virtue of the office assigned to him by the church, cares for
the poor and has charge of and distributes the money collected for their use
1c) a waiter, one who serves food and drink
Aquila and Priscilla
Priscilla and Aquila are referred to as "expounding the way" to Apollos, but
they are always mentioned together as husband and wife. Later it is mentioned that there
was a church in their house, but there is no statement of scripture of Priscilla being the
teacher. Three times her name is mentioned first, and three times his name is mentioned
first. There is no precedent for a woman to teach men under authority of a church board.
Rather, it shows that Priscilla and her husband ministered in the gospel together.
Although it is a narrow distinction, and not necessary for the doctrine,
expounding and teaching are different words. Aquila and Priscilla
were clearly testifying (expounding) the Gospel to Apollos, whereas teaching
has two different emphases, one is "to disciple", and the other is "to hold
discourse in order to instruct", and may include "expounding".
Comments:
- Authority of Scripture in the Church - We accept the authority of scripture in the
Church of Jesus Christ. Both in Apostolic times and throughout Church History, the Holy
Scriptures have been accepted as the only infallible source of guidance and direction for
ordering our personal lives, and the Church of Jesus Christ. See also 2 Tim 3:16,17
("Doctrine" - teachings on various subjects in the scriptures)
- Guidance by biblical authors such as Paul in all of their Biblical writings (see 2 Pe
3:15-18) is acknowledged and accepted by the believing church of all ages.
- Interpretation - Through the ages, non-literal interpretive methods (such as
"spiritualizing", "mystical", or "metaphorical") have arisen
even from godly men such as St. Thomas or St. Augustine. BUT the normative biblical
interpretive method accepted and used by Jesus, the Apostles, the early church, and the
Reformation, is to take scripture in it normal, natural sense unless the context shows a
symbolic, apocalyptic, or spiritual interpretation. Some scripture is obscure
and hard to understand in its original (OT) context, and its interpretation must be left
for the (NT) biblical authors. Much of the prophecies about Jesus and the end
times fall into this category and are interpreted for us by the biblical authors.
BUT issues of Christian practice generally do not fall into this category and their
interpretation for personal and church direction can be discerned and obeyed.
- This interpretive method above is described as the "inductive, historical,
grammatical, literary interpretation of scripture" (ala Luther, Matthew Henry,
Spurgeon, Howard Hendricks, etc.). Literary means understanding such communication devices
as parables, figures of speech, metaphor, simile, etc., but the straightforward meaning of
the text is clear. For instance, we dont really believe that God has His feathered
wings around us, but rather that He protects us personally.
- The women teaching men issue has been a randomly obeyed doctrine depending
upon the maturity of the church. See clear examples in 1st & 2nd
Corinthians, plus in Rev 2:20. However, in Orthodox churches through the centuries, this
has not been questioned until the recent accommodation to western culture in
evangelical churches.
- Culture does not supersede nor negate the teachings of Scripture.
- Church practices as established by the Apostolic Church, recorded in scripture, and
affirmed by the Biblical writers must be accepted as Gods standard for church
practice. There is no alternative for a Bible-believing church.
Summary:
Teaching & Authority are based upon the creative order. The man was created first
and has the authority and has the position of teaching men. 1 Tim 2:11-14 "A
woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or
to have authority over a man: she must be silent. For Adam was formed first, then
Eve." (NIV)
A woman is to be silent in church and ask questions to her husband, at home. 1 Cor
14:34-38 "women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to
speak, but must be in submission, as the Law says. 35 If they want to inquire about
something, they should ask their own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful for a woman
to speak in the church." (NIV)
Culture does not supersede nor negate the teachings of Scripture.
Once again, I caution the reader to discern whether this is a
"Cardinal Doctrine" - essential to salvation and godly living, or a
"Secondary Doctrine", or a
"Conviction", or "Opinion". The individual student must discern
their own beliefs, and with what vehemence to 'argue' their case. For me, this ranks as a personal "conviction",
and not either a "Secondary" nor "Cardinal"
doctrine.
My final word? - The Ministry of the Word, to the people of Gods Church, is never impeded by
obedience to the Word of God.